All Children Can Learn – A Reflection

This summer/fall I’m taking an additional qualifications course through the Ontario Principals Council titled “Special Education for Administrators”. As a preassignment, the course instructor, herself an experienced administrator in our district, has asked us to reflect on the following statement:

“All Children Can Learn”

She has asked us to frame our thoughts with the following questions in mind, as they pertain to special education:

  • What does that statement say to you?
  • How do you demonstrate that you believe this statement for students with special needs?
  • What concrete/specific actions have you taken thus far?
  • Do teachers believe it? How do teachers demonstrate this belief in your school?

This was difficult for me. My first response was, “Well, duh!” but that doesn’t fill the required two pages. But when I started to dig behind those four words, I realized there is so much that speaks to my whole philosophy of teaching, leading and learning; so much that I found it overwhelming. I went to my Tweeps for feedback with the hashtag #allchildrencanlearn and I thank those that took the time to respond or retweet. I’d like to keep the Twitter discussion going, but after several days of thinking and brainstorming, I came up with a reflection piece that I think encapsulates what the instructor wants us to think about. I thought I would share my reflection below:

Personal Reflection: All Children Can Learn

Erin Paynter

Special Education for Administrators, OPC

July 9, 2012

“Every student can learn, just not on the same day, or the same way.”
— George Evans

All children can learn.

However, I feel that there are some inherent issues within that statement that can be misleading. First is to address what it means to learn in general. Is it simply meeting expectations written in a document? Is it coming away with new facts that one didn’t know before? Is it being able to ask questions or critically analyze information? Is it the ability to be innovative or creative? What does that mean? Does a grade of A or B mean a student has learned something? The statement in itself begs many questions about learning in general.

Second, this statement can also be misleading if you take into account that at all levels (school, district and provincial), there is a heavy reliance on “final grades” and standardized testing that gives way to an assumption that all children learn the same way. To be certain, we are moving away from this assumption, but it remains an uphill battle in many ways.

But let’s say for the sake of argument that learning, on its surface, means meeting the expectations in the curriculum. Yes, I wholeheartedly believe that every student can learn (i.e., meet expectations). As a teacher, I show this through my use of differentiation in tasks and assessments based on interests, abilities and readiness levels. I recognize that all students progress along an individual path of growth and learning but at different paces (note that I did not use the word continuum as it implies a straight line, which to me learning is not, but that’s for another day). I plan intentionally with all my students in mind and all the resources I have available so that every student can demonstrate their knowledge in the way that utilizes their strengths and fills up the gaps. I hold students to high expectations, and support the students to get them there. I co-teach with colleagues so that there is time to work towards precise learning goals with small groups of students.

As an administrator I try to build and sustain a culture among staff that encapsulates this belief. I strive to create the conditions necessary for these beliefs to be met, through giving staff time in the form of school-based professional development, whether it’s at staff meetings, or release time during the instructional day where teachers can meet to plan, moderate student work, co-plan/write IEP’s, etc. It’s not enough, and to be honest, I am still running through my head what I have done and what I can do to better walk this talk.

But does my staff really believe this statement? I’m hesitant to say yes. When I reflect on some of the conversations I have had with some of my staff or that I’ve overheard in the staff room, it’s apparent that there is still a lot “victim-blaming” going on. When staff are expressing their frustrations at why students aren’t meeting expectations (theirs or curriculum – they are often mutually exclusive), the conversation among some shift to what it is about the student that is preventing them from “being good students”. They’re lazy, they’re irresponsible, they’re unfocused, and/or they just don’t care. I rarely hear “Perhaps the task wasn’t engaging enough, or, perhaps I didn’t allow for certain students to access the task in a way that best suits them, or, perhaps I need to expand my definition of differentiation beyond that-small-group-the-spec-ed-teacher-works-with”, or anything that does not involve a diatribe of all that is wrong with so-and-so, or that so-and-so is limited in what they can do because of an identification of an exceptionality. So I guess my answer to the question at the opening of the paragraph is: not really, not yet. And the not yet part is where I, as an administrator, come in because gone are the days where it is acceptable or natural for educators to blame the student for not achieving or not doing well according to a set of homogeneous standards (i.e., curriculum). It is our duty and responsibility as educators to take every child in our care and support them in any way that, in the words of a colleague, “allows them to shine”.

Through this course I hope to refine my goals as an administrator when it comes to supporting all the students in my care, especially our most vulnerable students. My site has two systems (special education) classes – one for students with learning disabilities, and another for students with behaviour issues, as well as the myriad of students who are in the mainstream classes with special needs, from learning disabilities, toASD, to anxiety disorders and mild intellectual delays.

Some of my goals are:

  • to be more purposeful in the questions I ask of teachers when it comes to the achievement of all students, especially students with special needs. If there is victim-blaming, what kinds of questions can I ask that support self-reflection among my staff when it comes to the students with special needs in their classes?
  • to reflect and explore what concrete strategies/actions I can take to support my staff so that they are supporting their exceptional students in ways that best meet their needs
  • to reach out beyond my school and invite other support agencies in as an additional resource to my staff and my parent community
  • embed this philosophy into our School Improvement Plan for Student Achievement through the use instructional strategies, assessment strategies and look-fors that best support all our learners
  • to take a more appreciative stance when reflecting on the staff in my building so that we can build together on what we do well and address what needs changing

Ultimately, as an administrator, I will strive to work with my staff and my parent community to explore some of the more abstract and bigger issues that are at hand; namely to redefine what we believe to be learning; to really ask ourselves what we are saying through the way we assess and evaluate students with special needs and students in general, and to reflect on the goals we set for our students with special needs so that we push ourselves beyond seeing achievement as being tied to meeting a list of expectations.

So that’s my first crack at it. As I let it sit for a few hours, or until tomorrow, I may revise it. As my valued PLN, I welcome your feedback.

10 thoughts on “All Children Can Learn – A Reflection

  1. Nice job with this post, Erin. I think it’s critical for school leaders to focus on multiple measures of student learning, which is even more important for our special education students. It is not uncommon for those administrators who reside among a state’s or school district’s highest perches to tout the importance of differentiating/individualized instruction for all students, yet they fail to stress the importance of different methods for assessing student learning. We certainly can’t expect to teach all students using the same programs and instructional strategies, yet many times we are asked to assess the progress of the general and special education student populations with the same standardized test. I still have trouble with this approach, yet I believe it remains a very common practice. As you stated above, engaging your school’s community to redefine learning is a very important step to take. Schools need to do this on a much larger scale. Let’s hope they follow your lead.

    • I also think that a common idea of what learning really is must be realized on a systems level to really do right by all our students in our care, and not just by ticking off a list of expectations, as I wrote. I hope that this course will help.

  2. You know i’ve noticed my kids learn best when they are positive so focus on stuff that keeps them laughing here is a website that has an education secion. familys101.org they offer a computer learning program and my daughter loves it. 🙂

  3. I was “Googling” educational quotes-specifically the “Every child can learn but not the same way . . .” quote. I cam across your statement and really enjoyed reading it. In Louisiana USA, we are beginning a new accountability system for teachers that takes student achievement as a big part of the “score.” I’ve found myself playing that blame game! I’m going to really rethink that attitude as I head back to school.

    • Hi Tory. Thanks for taking the time to write a comment. I think it’s great when educators are reflective and commit to shifting their practice for what’s best for students. Having said that, making teachers accountable for student test scores makes me very nervous. Standardized test scores do a great job at predicting student performance on standardized tests, not learning. They measure each other. I prefer to look at building capacity within teacher practitioners so that their practice best meets the needs of students so that they are successful.
      All the best.
      Erin

  4. Erin, I am a student at USA in Mobile, Alabama http://murphydeborahedm310.blogspot.com/ and was assigned to read your blog and respond now and again on September 13, 2012 by Dr. John Strange at http://edm310.blogspot.com/.
    I read your reflection of children’s ability to learn. I agree that learning needs to be analyzed in light of its complexities. In addition, the current standards by which we measure success do need to be addressed. As technology moves our world forward at a faster and faster pace, the traditional ways that we have looked at learning and measuring its success will need to change. Maybe, I thought, “This change starts with teachers.” Then I was moved by the “victim blaming” and began to search myself, “Maybe the change starts with me.” Thank you.

    • Hi Ann. I’m honored to have you learning alongside me! Thank you for your comments. The “victim blaming” comment always resonates with me. As educators we always want our kids to be learning and we struggle to figure why this sometimes doesn’t happen. Too often we hear “He has what it takes, but he just won’t ________!” My learning has been how can I frame a supportive response as an administrator that both supports my teachers and opens up a reflective dialogue where perhaps they feel secure enough to look inward and, as you say, begin the change within themselves.
      Look forward to hearing from you again! Best of luck!
      Erin

  5. My Grandfather told me that you get more flies with honey than you do with vinegar. I think the original meaning was that you get more friends by being nice to them. But, this same concept is true when you are trying to critique or help someone to learn from their mistakes. When someone is mean or harsh, your emotions get involved in a negative way and all you can think about is how you are hurting and you don’t hear what they are saying. But, when you are complimented, it opens your heart and mind to receive more.

  6. Hello there! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when viewing from my iphone4. I’m
    trying to find a theme or plugin that might be
    able to resolve this issue. If you have any suggestions, please share.
    Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s